We started the day quite late, but we are on vacation, so who cares? The Pope’s big events were today, and Paris was pretty locked down—streets blocked, Métro stations closed, and police everywhere.
Cathy thinks Paris sometimes feels like a movie set, and she is right. It is almost too perfect: beautiful architecture, sidewalk cafés, people walking and bicycling everywhere, and seemingly everyone looking as though they belong in Paris. The Marais, where we are staying, is especially congested, but in a good way. It feels alive.
We took a long walk and bought some gifts for friends back in the States, then returned to the hotel to prepare for dinner.
But first there was the matter of the bottle of Champagne the hotel had given us. We obviously weren’t going to take it home, and wasting Champagne would be irresponsible, so we brought it down to the courtyard and drank it. Problem solved.
Then it was time to head off to my dream restaurant: L’Ami Louis.
Cathy claims I have been talking about eating there for only 20 years. I think it has been much longer. Either way, she has had to listen to me talk about it for far too long, and tonight the quest was finally going to end.
L’Ami Louis is tiny and wood-paneled, and it reminded both of us of an old-fashioned train dining car. It was recently bought by Bernard Arnault, the chairman of LVMH and one of the richest men in the world. His empire includes Louis Vuitton, Dior and a large portion of the things people buy when they have considerably more money than they need. He is also behind the Fondation Louis Vuitton, the spectacular Frank Gehry-designed museum that, unfortunately for us, is closed while they install a new exhibition.
And now he owns L’Ami Louis.
Cathy chose a great wine, a Volnay Premier Cru Clos. Spoiler alert: the wine was the best part of dinner.
I ordered exactly what L’Ami Louis is famous for: foie gras, potatoes and, of course, the chicken. I knew dinner was going to be expensive. I just assumed it was also going to be great.
The foie gras arrived in several enormous slabs. It was rich and good, but there was far more than any two normal human beings could possibly eat. There was one very nice touch: halfway through they replaced our bread, explaining that the new bread was hot and therefore better with the foie gras. They were right.
Rather than critique every course, I’ll get to the point.
We have had better chicken at Zuni Café in San Francisco and at numerous restaurants in Los Angeles like Republique or Henryetta.
For years I had read that people fell into two camps about L’Ami Louis. Half thought it was one of the greatest meals of their lives. The other half thought it was wildly overrated.
Put us firmly in the second camp.
The meal wasn’t bad. It was ok. But after 20—or possibly 30—years of anticipation, “ok” was not exactly what I had in mind.
Still, I am happy I finally went. The quest is over. I can cross L’Ami Louis off the list and look back fondly on a very good bottle of Volnay.
We had plenty of leftovers, and my original plan was to take the chicken back to the hotel and ask the chef to make chicken sandwiches for us for lunch the next day. We left the restaurant carrying a large bag containing chicken and a considerable amount of foie gras.
By the time we reached the hotel, however, neither of us wanted to eat any of it again. Why spend tomorrow’s lunch being reminded of tonight’s dinner?
Then Cathy remembered that in an alley adjoining our hotel there were two tents where homeless people were sleeping.
So I took our large bag of L’Ami Louis chicken and foie gras over and left it between the two tents.
Hopefully, tomorrow morning someone will wake up, unzip their tent and discover that breakfast has been catered by one of the most famous restaurants in Paris.
The world is going to hell, so on any realistic scale an overpriced, disappointing chicken dinner ranks pretty low among life’s tragedies.
But I am still left with one question.
What were all those people who raved about L’Ami Louis thinking?
Maybe it is the history. Maybe it is the exclusivity. Maybe it is the status of being able to say you ate there.
Or maybe they had more Volnay than we did.